2 wheel or 4 wheel drive?

Discussion in 'Lounge & Gossip' started by Richard Coleman, Wednesday 10th May, 2017.

  1. Richard Coleman New Member Getting Started

    Portugal Richard Tavira
    4
    5
    Hello, can some please give me some advice regarding a 2000 HR-V. I have owned this car in Portugal for 6 years and enjoyed total trouble free motoring. However yesterday I took the car for its MOT and was told it was going to fail because it didn't have a prop-shaft fitted. The car has never had a prop-shaft since I bought it and has been front wheel drive only with no issues. I know there was a option of 2 or 4 wheel drive when these cars were new but am unsure if there should be a prop-shaft fitted. There are connections from both the gearbox and the rear differential to accommodate. Can anyone advise and explain why this should be a MOT failure?
     
  2. Davej5 Premium Member Club Supporter

    Dave Cornwall
    170
    98
    If it has a rear diff and connections it must have been 4WD was the MOT in Portugal? I would not have thought it would be a failure here as it is not affecting safety.
     
    Loading...
    andy83 likes this.
  3. Richard Coleman New Member Getting Started

    Portugal Richard Tavira
    4
    5
    Yes the test was in Portugal ( where it has passed for the last 5 years at the same test centre) I suspected it was originally the intelligent 4 wheel drive but like you I can't see why only using the 2 wheel drive would be a safety issue. I'm more concerned why the shaft is missing? May be a problem with the rear diff which I don't want to change when I don't need it!
     
    honda_saj likes this.
  4. honda_saj Banned

    United Kingdom saj east london
    1,288
    713
    2
    Did you not ask garage why they have passed all these years prior to now ? was there a new inspector or same ?
     
    Loading...
  5. Richard Coleman New Member Getting Started

    Portugal Richard Tavira
    4
    5
    It is not like the UK here where you take your car to a garage for the test. They have dedicated inspection centres which pass or fail your car. You can not "discuss" things with a mechanic like in the UK.
     
    honda_saj likes this.
  6. honda_saj Banned

    United Kingdom saj east london
    1,288
    713
    2
    ok not aware of procedure in your country :nodding:
     
    Loading...
  7. MickyB Club Veteran ★ ★ ★ ★ ★

    Your procedure is like Spain then.
    Having owned a 4WD 1 gen HR-V for some years I could only comment that the rear diff would rumble on a full lock which went with a diff flush and service.
    I would think that the propsheft had a problem hence being removed I can't see the diff seizing as the wheels wouldn't turn(I presume).someone please correct me if I'm wrong.
    I would hazard a guess at the diff rumbling and the previous owner being told the diff is broken and the easy option being to remove the prop shaft, I honestly can't see any other reason why it would be removed as I said unless the propshaft was damaged.
    You wouldn't know the answer to either unless you fitted a propshaft.
    Hope that makes some sort of sense.
     
    Loading...
    andy83 likes this.
  8. andy83 Club Veteran ★ ★ ★ ★ ★

    United Kingdom andy shropshire
    2,735
    2,107
    3
    I had this with a 1st Generation CR-V did flush with diff fluid and it stopped, so good points by @MickyB :Hey::Thumbup:..
    Thanks
    Andy
     
    Loading...
    MickyB likes this.
  9. Richard Coleman New Member Getting Started

    Portugal Richard Tavira
    4
    5
    Thanks for the response, I will fit a prop-shaft and flush the diff if it sounds bad. I was thinking it may have been a faulty centre bearing that made them ditch the prop in the first place. If the diff plays up I will let them test the car with the shaft fitted then take it off.
     
    MickyB, 1066Boy and andy83 like this.
  10. andy83 Club Veteran ★ ★ ★ ★ ★

    United Kingdom andy shropshire
    2,735
    2,107
    3
    Loading...
    MickyB likes this.
  11. 1066Boy Premium Member Club Supporter

    Sounds like a good plan. I have to refit my anti-roll bar to the Suzuki every time its tested and then take it strait back off again after the MOT. :Devil:
     
    Loading...
    MickyB likes this.
  12. Davej5 Premium Member Club Supporter

    Dave Cornwall
    170
    98
    It could have been the prop shaft universal joints that were gone if they are like the CR-V they are difficult to source and Honda only sell the complete assembly.
     
    Loading...
    honda_saj and andy83 like this.